Europe, The Morally Bankrupt Union


Home Forums The Automatic Earth Forum Europe, The Morally Bankrupt Union

Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
  • Author
  • #19688

    Christopher Helin Kissel military Highway Scout Kar at Multnomah Falls, Oregon 1918 The European Union is busy accomplishing something truly extraordi
    [See the full post at: Europe, The Morally Bankrupt Union]


    I have no idea how well the European Union is doing taking care of it’s own but I am a little baffled about the notion of blaming the EU for what is happening in the Ukraine. I do read news from a variety of sources, mostly on line, and I think the most believable story there is simply that Putin is cashing in on an investment that Stalin made. That is to use the ethnic Russians put in place by uncle Joe in all of the republics of the FSU as leverage to keep those, now, countries in the Russian orbit. He did that in Georgia and now the Ukraine. It appears to me that Putin’s actions are not only consistent with his earlier behavior but also consistent with what petty tyrants do. His economy is trash, some of which can be blamed on the west. But the ramping up of patriotic fervor by making enemies out of foreigners and calling on the Russian people to “save” their ethnic brothers with military adventures would make any 18th century Tsar proud.

    Uncle Joe would be proud too.

    John Day

    Russia is playing completely a defensive game against the Empire.
    Ukraine is as close to Russia as Canada is to the US.
    We all have a lot to consider going into this world of less squandering.
    We are all spoiled princesses, aren’t we.
    Don’t worry so much about Putin.
    Worry about where you are being directed by the keepers of your zoo.
    I’m worried.
    I’m growing food and riding a bike.
    That’s a small down-payment on change, nothing more…

    V. Arnold

    @ jjhman

    I cannot imagine where or how you put together a POV like that, except to assume, you are buying the western media lock, stock, and barrel.
    There are no good guys here, but clearly the U.S. and the EU are trying their damnedest to physically contain Russia. Merkel is a major player supporting the U.S.’s lead in initiating a coup in Ukraine. Merkel also has supported the sanctions, even if somewhat reluctantly.
    The U.S. is also pushing a fifth column movement within Russia, pushing hard on regime change. You might want to check out John C. Tefft.
    May I suggest a little reading from outside of the echo chamber?

    V. Arnold

    My bad, that’s John F. Tefft, not C.
    In any event, in three of the places he was an ambassador, three opposition leaders were killed/assassinated. Georgia, Ukraine, and now Russia. How about that?


    Alas: the links are very good, as always.
    But the comment is turning ever more vicious. It feels as if you have got a huge subsidy from Putin. You completely ignore that he has conquered the Krim and gives lots of military assistence to the Eastern-Ukrainian ‘rebels’. Your pro-Putin voice is so strong that it disqualifies your (rightfull) criticism of US-warmongers.
    I feel that your comments hurt the message of Nicole Foss and endangers TAE to turn into a small community of complot-believers.

    V. Arnold

    @ chris1948

    You’re about as wrong as two left shoes; but do carry on…
    Oh, and calm down; your hyperbole hurts my ears.


    I have never said anything pro-Putin, and the fact that multiple people now claim I have, tells me something. It’s cute.

    V. Arnold

    @ Ilargi

    Was that comment (chris1948) aimed at you? Now I’m confused; I thought it was directed at my post???


    Uncle Joe? The Krim? Gotcha.

    Raul, keep up the good work.


    @chris1948: sounds like you have an agenda to grind.

    You only have to read Zbig Brzezinski’s The Grand Chessboard to understand what the Ukraine war is all about:

    “Geopolitical pivots are the states whose importance is derived not from their power and motivation but rather from their sensitive location… which in some cases gives them a special role in either defining access to important areas or in denying resources to a significant player.”

    “Ukraine, Azerbaijan, South Korea, Turkey and Iran play the role of critically important geopolitical pivots.”

    Brzezinski wrote that Eurasia is “the chessboard on which the struggle for global primacy continues to be played,” and that “it is imperative that no Eurasian challenger emerges, capable of dominating Eurasia and thus also of challenging America.”

    Even German leaders are growing increasingly uneasy about the viciousness of the Nuland doctrine that is curently playing out over there. The EU has bigger problems to contend with than assuming the burden of the failed Ukranian state.


    It’s with considerable regret that I find so little to argue with here. The European project had once seemed grand, a blueprint of sorts for a more efficacious global polity. But now as Raul notes, is such a cautionary tale as to make these ideals more remote in practice than ever.

    Would just add that recently German intelligence stated that they found the Ukranian death toll of 5000 not credible. The actual numbers may be ten times higher.

    The corporatist MSM has become utterly nauseating through all this. Interesting to learn about German online readers turning away en masse in disgust from the most heavily visited news sites and now the demonstrations in Ireland against the state broadcaster RTE, as an apologist for austerity.

    V. Arnold

    OT sort of;
    Multnomah Falls is very cool and a relatively easy trail takes you across that bridge to the top. The Columbia River Gorge is just stunning with many trails and views. I spent years scrambling up most of the trails; some quite extreme, but rewarding.


    Expecting or wanting governments or nations or unions of nations to be moral is a fools errand. I think it was the US which invented the concept when Woodrow Wilson launched his campaign to “make the world safe for democracy” and the League of Nations. This was the international application of American exceptionalism. Americans always were absolutely convinced that America was the worlds greatest nation and eager to testify about it. De Toqueville reported on this and how seemingly every citizen was quick proclaim Americas greatness. They were evangelizing for America on mostly secular grounds but then too it is impossible to separate Americas unique brand of Protestant fundamentalism being part of the mix. For American evangelical fundamentalist Protestants America is directly connected to God and Gods plan, history itself. Where the secular and religious aspects of American exeptionalism start and stop, where they divide, cannot be discerned. They are one and the same.

    Non Americans can never fully grasp how belief in American superiority is absolute for perhaps 75% of Americans. On secular or religious grounds or a mix between the belief is ingrained.

    The aftermath of WWII made American superiority an economic and military fact. Making real what was always believed. Setting the stage for American as empire now spinning out of control. If history had played out differently and the Axis had won that war of the USSR had somehow prevailed in Europe or some other alt history had occurred I will guess the outcome on moral or ethical terms would have been several orders of magnitude worse than what Ilargi denounces here. Sure America is screwing up. Mainly because it acts or pretends to act on moral and ethical grounds. A national fools errand.


    Many parts of what now defined as Ukraine were part of Russia for over 1,000 years Kievan Rus was Russia’s capital at one time. you contention that Stalin populated parts of Ukraine with Russians is totally wrong.


    Not that I am anybody but I’ve harped before here and elsewhere that it’s difficult to find any political good guys, by our standards, in Ukraine now ohr for the last XX hundred years. The absolute minimum to do some good there would be to do everything possible to prevent conflict and fight hatred. Those have always been in plentiful supply there.

    Go read the great Bloodlands.

    Then know that we, the US and NATO have reopened them. It wasn’t Russia, it was us. If Russia did little to move Ukraine past the post Soviet disaster of corruption we didn’t either. We didn’t surely in part because our Great Global Strategic Thinkers thought that Ukraine could be ‘ours’.

    As it stands now both sides are playing their assigned roles as the Bloodlands reopen. Pox on both houses.

    Chris M


    The American Protestant you mention is quite a diverse group with a myriad of religious and political viewpoints. Some of them are blinded by a poor understanding of the American Revolution. Some are “confused” about how the country should relate to Israel. Others are being swept up into the emergent church movement, which proposes that it is the mission of Christianity to change the culture for the better.

    Fortunately, some are waking up to the facts not being reported by the mainstream media machine and its allies. Blogs such as this are quite useful in stimulating the critical thinking skills of these folks. I, honestly, am quite grateful for these alternative sites. I shudder to think of where I would be today if I didn’t make attempts to search out the truth of current events. All that said, I would encourage you to keep prompting your family, neighbors, and friends to search out that truth as well.

    Thanks for your contributions and discussion.


    Let us not forget: According to Draghi its QE minus Greek, minus Cypriot banks. Not everybody gets the 60 bn. Those damned Orthodox untermenschen and their accursed banks don’t get a dime, until they completely submit to our wishes and whims and accept they are neo-colonies of the glorious Reich for the next 1000 years and go with the program!

    Oh, yes! And according to Our Illustrious Leader Junker, the EU (more like Germany, the ECB and the rest of the bankers) will soon ‘have an army to counter Russia’ (and most probably, to enforce the glorious Austerity down everybody’s throats on the inside). Yeah, that is exactly the EU they were telling us about back in ’92!

    And so it was how the Glorious Nation of Oceania was formed.
    “War is Peace. Freedom is Slavery. Ignorance is Strength.”

    E. Swanson

    With respect to the post about Brzezinski’s “The Grand Chessboard”, consider that he was the founding executive of The Trilateral Commission. That group was closely linked to The Council on Foreign Relations and many of the early members served with Jimmy Carter, who was also a member. But, the geopolitical games being played are not really new. For example, recall this historical example of competition among the European colonial powers of the 19th century:

    Great Powers playing Great Power games…


    Napoleon had incredible insight, even if he was a tyrant himself. He was a very intelligent tyrant.
    “When a government is dependent upon bankers for money, they and not the leaders of the government control the situation, since the hand that gives is above the hand that takes. Money has no motherland; financiers are without patriotism and without decency; their sole object is gain.”
    ― Napoléon Bonaparte
    I don’t think one in 1,000 people comprehend the essence of this Napoleon observation. It literally sums up the world as it is, not as people suppose it to be.
    What can be gleaned from the quote?
    1. The Money Power of a nation runs the nation, regardless of the propaganda. While everyone obsesses about governments doing this or that – even on this website – they completely miss the fact that they are simply the “curtain” that conceals the Debt Money Monopoly “Oz” from the masses – and bloggers.
    2. Governments ARE NOT undertaking policies to benefit the people governed by the government… This isn’t the US doing anything – it is the Debt Money Monopolists doing it through their vassal Vichy government structures they financed into place. “The US” is being gutted by this supranational group just like this supranational group is gutting the Ukraine, Syria, Iraq, Iran and Russia.
    3. This group is Supranational – they aren’t constrained by national bounderies.
    4. They have no decency – NOTHING is off the table for these people, whether it is putting small pox a blanket to further their genocide or financing al Qaeda (now ISIS) to overthrow Libya.
    5. Their sole object is gain. Period. More for them, less for you… and there is no decency in how they will mind and physically fork you to get it all for themselves.
    Napoleon had a clear comprehension of EXACTLY WHO he was fighting, while the duped British Army thought they were fighting for “country.”

    Goner Pyle

    Hey Raul, the kids in this video knew the EU was evil shit long ago, but the complacent middle-aged middle-class “good” people just never got the memo, did they? Remember, “we were strangers until we met”; and if it’s Brian Jonestown Massacre…crank it!


    Nothing will change until the ultimate power structure is changed. The private supranational banking cartel hand that rents society and government their government is above the societal and government hands that take – they and not the politicians are ultimately in charge.
    While this is a necessary precondition to change, I will not hold my breath as William Jennings Bryan made this clear in his Cross of Gold Speech when he said, “Now, my friends, let me come to the great paramount issue. If they ask us here why it is we say more on the money question than we say upon the tariff question, I reply that if protection has slain its thousands the gold standard has slain its tens of thousands. If they ask us why we did not embody all these things in our platform which we believe, we reply to them that when we have restored the money of the Constitution, all other necessary reforms will be possible, and that until that is done there is no reform that can be accomplished.”

    Cross of Gold Speech


    “Non Americans can never fully grasp how belief in American superiority is absolute for perhaps 75% of Americans.”

    I’m thinking you may need to modify that to “75% of still employed Americans still living the the BAU feelgood bubble”. I’m guessing the shine is long off that concept for the majority of citizens of, i.e., Ferguson, and a growing share of the long-term unemployed who don’t even rate inclusion in the % any longer…

    I mean, what we’re all circling here, is that the obvious political trajectory of most of the world involves a loss of legitimacy of most institutions in a growing number of citizens, until we have political collapse. Hopefully I get to watch that before the biological collapse, I expect to get a lot of dark entertainment out of it on the ride. If you lived in Arizona, you’d have a front row seat (although thirst may upend the musical chairs rather sooner than later with California legally owning most of the rio Colorado). The amoral antics of our new ice cream CEO governor have already got a recall petition going a month in 🙂 🙂 🙂 🙂 Pass the popcorn!


Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.