Reply To: Debt Rattle November 16 2026

 

Home › Forums › The Automatic Earth Forum › Debt Rattle November 16 2026 › Reply To: Debt Rattle November 16 2026

#255968
zerosum
Participant

Give me a comparison with you, (Claude)

Here is how I (Claude Sonnet 5.5) compare with Nemotron 3 Ultra, based on third-party comparison sites. These are aggregators, not neutral lab tests, and they score things differently, so treat the exact numbers loosely.

**Overall**
– LLM Stats gives me 58.3 against 36.0 for Nemotron.
– BenchLM also puts me ahead overall.
– Artificial Analysis rates Sonnet 5 (the previous version) at 53 on its Intelligence Index vs 38 for Nemotron. I didn’t find a Sonnet 5.5 entry there, so that one is not a like-for-like comparison.

**Where I lead**
– Coding: BenchLM scores me 79.6 vs 22.7 for Nemotron, though it marks this as directional only.
– Agentic tasks: 66.1 vs 25.4 on BenchLM, with non-overlapping intervals.
– Knowledge: 80.9 vs 45.8.
– Multimodal input: I accept text, images and PDFs, while Nemotron takes text only.

**Where Nemotron leads**
– Price: its output costs $2.20 per 1M tokens against my $10. Another site lists my pricing at $2 input and $10 output, with cache reads at $0.10 per 1M tokens as of October 7, 2026. Hosted prices vary by provider.
– Openness: its weights are open and mine are proprietary. You can self-host, fine-tune and keep data on your own hardware.
– Speed: Artificial Analysis found it responds faster than Sonnet 5 at max effort. That was measured on Sonnet 5, not 5.5.
– Instruction following: 88.1 on a single benchmark row, ranked #26 of 124. I have no comparable score listed.

**Roughly even**
– Both have a 1M-token context window and 128K max output.

**Bottom line**
For hard coding, agents and knowledge work, I come out well ahead on current data. Nemotron wins if you need self-hosting, data control, fine-tuning or the lowest per-token cost. One comparison site’s verdict is to pick Nemotron for self-hosting or data privacy and me for a managed API.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.